News
McCool Teacher Tracy Cole Defends Proposed Mackenzie Move and Calls for More Opportunity for Every Student
Filed November 19, 2026

McCool Teacher Tracy Cole Defends Proposed Mackenzie Move and Calls for More Opportunity for Every Student
A Lubbock ISD teacher is defending the proposed combination of Commander William C. McCool Academy and Mackenzie Middle School while challenging adults to stop speaking negatively about the children who would be affected.
Under the proposal described by McCool English language arts teacher Tracy Cole, McCool Academy would move from its current building at 4402 31st Street into the Mackenzie campus at 5402 12th Street. The McCool name and academic model would continue, while Mackenzie would no longer operate under its current name.
“McCool Academy is not going anywhere. It is relocating,” Cole wrote. “That building will become McCool Academy, and Mackenzie Junior High or Middle School will no longer exist under that name.”
The plan remains a proposal. The Lubbock ISD Student Achievement and Engagement Committee discussed an optimization update on November 17, but the publicly available minutes do not document a final board vote approving the move.
Lubbock ISD’s official optimization dashboard shows Mackenzie currently meets all three district criteria used to consider a campus for consolidation. Mackenzie has 359 students, a three year enrollment average of 385, current building use of 46 percent and per student spending of $7,681. The campus received a D rating with a score of 63 for 2026.
McCool meets two of the three criteria. Its current enrollment is 471 with a three year average of 446. Building use is 68.9 percent, but its per student spending of $6,393 is below the district average. McCool received an A rating with a score of 90 for 2026.
Cole argued that McCool’s success comes from its people and culture rather than its current address.
“What makes McCool different isn’t where it is. It’s who is there,” Cole wrote. “The teachers. The relationships. The expectations. The culture. The results.”
She said the staff earned support from families and the community through what it accomplished with students, but emphasized that Mackenzie students deserve access to the same opportunities.
“The students currently attending Mackenzie deserve those same opportunities,” Cole wrote. “Relocating creates opportunities to expand programs, including CTE options, that the current McCool building simply doesn’t have the space to accommodate.”
Cole said the most troubling part of the public debate has been the language some adults have used while discussing Mackenzie students and employees.
“What has been most disheartening, however, is watching how adults have spoken about children throughout this conversation,” Cole wrote. “Children who deserve a collective group of adults who know them, believe in them, and speak to the champion within them.”
She also defended Mackenzie educators who continue working with students while reading public criticism of their campus.
“Imagine showing up every day, pouring into students, and then opening social media to read commentary from people who wouldn’t even purchase a pack of pencils for your campus but have suddenly become experts on everything happening inside it,” Cole wrote.
Cole clarified that McCool uses the same district purchased curriculum and assessments as other Lubbock ISD middle schools.
“We still have the same middle school love in the air and enough Axe body spray in the hallways to make your eyes water,” she wrote. “The difference is the culture that has been built.”
She rejected the idea that McCool’s educational opportunities should remain limited to families who understood its application process.
“Just because your child was accepted into a program doesn’t mean a child whose family didn’t know those opportunities existed deserves any less,” Cole wrote. “That’s where grace should enter the conversation.”
Cole said parents and community members have every right to question transportation, staffing, academic programs and other transition details. She argued, however, that those concerns should never become attacks on Mackenzie children or employees.
“You can have questions about the transition. You can have concerns about the logistics. You can even disagree with the decision,” Cole wrote. “But you should never make children or the educators who serve them feel like they are somehow less deserving of opportunity.”
Cole concluded that the discussion should focus on giving more students access to strong programs.
“The goal should not be to protect opportunities for a select few,” she wrote. “It should be to expand them for more children. And that is a conversation worth having.”
Sponsored by System X Technologies.
Help The806er continue providing independent local coverage by liking, commenting and sharing this story.



